Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Regular price $36.99 Sale

Chocolate Birthday Plaque
Chocolate Birthday Plaque
$2.99
Gold Celebration Candles
Gold Celebration Candles
$4.99

A tangy, key lime filling that's both perfectly sweet and tart in a graham cracker crust with a thin layer of cookie butter. Finished with a lightly toasted meringue.

Shipping box (small).
Small
(1 Pie)

Just a taste

Shipping box (large).
Large
(2 Pies)

Perfect for
a party

What Our Guests Are Saying:

Customer Reviews

Based on 11 reviews
73%
(8)
9%
(1)
9%
(1)
0%
(0)
9%
(1)
D
D.F.
Best Key lime pie ever

I ordered a key lime pie for a cookout my boyfriend and I were hosting. Key lime is his favorite. The sticky sweet meringue along with the tart filling and delicious crust made this one of the best we’ve ever had. Absolutely delicious.

V
V.L.
Incredible!!

Enjoyed a slice at a friend’s BBQ and oh my goodness here I am still thinking about it the next day. 10/10 recommend - already thinking of an excuse to order one!

S
Sue

Just received it. Unfortunately the meringue has slid to one side of the pie.
I’m sure it will be good but a few people won’t have the meringue topping.

Hello Sue,

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave a review. We are discouraged to hear about your experience. As you can imagine this is not the experience we strive to provide. We are delighted to know that Elise was able to connect with you and discuss your concerns. She is happy to assist you in the future! Please feel free to email us any time so our team can personally connect with you.

Have a sweet day!

Rosa
Porto's Bake at Home

H
H.J.
Key Lime pie

Very good, but.
Please please bring back the tuna melt, it was soooooo good. I miss that sandwich.

M
M.J.
Key lime pie

Definitely not the same miniature pie they used to have before the pandemic hit. Miss that little pie :(

Your Cart
Left arrow Menu Close button

Your Cart is Currently Empty

Complete Your Order With:

What zip code are you shipping to?

Green Check mark

When do you want it delivered?

Order now! Most items stay fresh for
40 days if frozen.
Left chevron Right chevron
SUN
MON
TUE
WED
THU
FRI
SAT
Present Icon Add a Gift Message Plus sign button Minus sign button
0/275
Subtotal $0.00
Checkout
Close button
Light tan dark brown checkmark Item added to order Added to order